User:QJ Lincoln/Sandbox

From eRepublik Official Wiki
Jump to: navigation, search

Please review these policies below. We have pretty much been using these as guidelines all along, but some editors wanted to discuss. Each section has a policy statement and the rationale. Please vote and/or discuss.

Contents

Nav Boxes

Navigation boxes should be used sparingly and only on pages that are in the "Playing the Game" category. These boxes can be used in the "User" name space. Navigation box templates should use the standard template Template:Navboxes.
Rationale: Most times the nav box isn't needed because it duplicates what can be found by clicking category. They can be ugly. They are not helpful to readers on citizen pages because readers don't care about your sandbox, signature, user page, etc. Most of those things are linked to in the article.

Navbox placement is in the nav template, the "playing the game category" is Category:Playing the Game--QJ Lincoln Talk To Me 22:22, 2 July 2010 (UTC)
Then I am definitely not going to agree with this. Just because the Wiki as it stands right now does not have enough content to expand to other areas where naviboxes would be useful does not mean you can dictate how to hamper further development. For instance, USA might decide create a navibox to associate all of its country's government, political, and military articles into one big navibox like how they do it on Wikipedia all the time. Even if this is developed to produce a productive and useful internal link library, this policy would bar these developers from doing so. It is not fair and it should not be passed. Icon-USA.png - Jameson L. Tai talk/United States Rangers 23:53, 2 July 2010 (UTC)

Votes

5-3, For the policy. I have updated the policy to incorporate the suggestions by the No voters.
Navigation boxes boxes on pages that link related articles. For example:


Health and what influences it

Health · Food · House · Hospital · Health kit · Training · Working · Fightinh · Moving ticket

Navigation box templates should use the standard template Template:Navboxes to maintain the common look of the wiki. Navigation boxes should be used sparingly and only to link related concepts. Navigation boxes should only be used on general interest pages, such as those describing game concepts. They should not be used on citizen pages. However, these boxes can be used in the "User" name space, if the editor desires.
Rationale: In most cases, a navigation box isn't needed because it duplicates what can be found in wikilinks throughout the article or by clicking the category. Instead of creating a navigation box, editors are encouraged to work these links into the text of the article or create a "See Also" section.

Citizen Pages

Vote: 8-1 for the policy Citizen pages are about the citizen/character/game entity from the game eRepublik. At minimum, the citizen page should have the citizen template (with avatar image) and text describing the citizen and his or her activities in the game. Citizen pages, like all other pages in the wiki, should be factual, neutral, and link to other wiki pages. The page should be written in the third person. Citizen pages should refrain from including details that change often (skills, employers) that are readily evident on in game citizen pages. The only exception to this is the Achievement Templates. If a wiki editor has a citizen page, he or she is welcome to place a link to his or her user page. However, the editor should not describe contribution or wiki activities on the citizen page, this information is for the user page.
Rationale: Regularity and common design. Keeping pages relevant instead of having to update as often.

We are not going to dictate how people structure their articles... that is it. This is not wikipedia. We have always allowed a certain amount of leniency to what people want to write about. I refuse to place people into little boxes and stifle creativity. every eRepublik:Fictional content policy and eRepublik:Reference policy. I don't understand the need to state how many links a page should have. I am not going to further explain things that change often because it explains why it isn't a good idea to put skills and employers on a page.--QJ Lincoln Talk To Me 22:22, 2 July 2010 (UTC)
  • Then you are contradicting yourself to the fullest. Your rationale states "Regularity and common design." but you then say in your own explanation that you "are not going to dictate how people structure their articles". Which one is it? You are saying that people need to have a common design, so that design would naturally have a specific structure. Your wishy-washy attitude towards this does not positively contribute to a be-all-end-all policy, rather create more bureaucratic bullshit where whichever direction sysops want the wind to blow would be right without specifying what exactly is the precise intent. Therefore it bears no purpose and thus, I strongly oppose. Icon-USA.png - Jameson L. Tai talk/United States Rangers 23:58, 2 July 2010 (UTC)

Votes

Vote: 8-1 for the policy Citizen pages are about the citizen/character/game entity from the game eRepublik. At minimum, the citizen page should have the citizen template (with avatar image) and text describing the citizen and his or her activities in the game. Citizen pages, like all other pages in the wiki, should be factual, neutral, and link to other wiki pages. Citizen pages should not use details that change often (skills, employers) that are readily evident on in game citizen pages. The only exception to this is the Achievement Templates. If a wiki editor has a citizen page, he or she is welcome to place a link to his or her user page. However, the editor should not describe contribution or wiki activities on the citizen page, this information is for the user page.

User Pages

User pages are for the the wiki editor to talk about his or her real life or wiki contributions. The user talk pages are used to leave messages/have conversations with wiki editors. The user namespace can and should be used for the development of articles or templates. Pages in the user name space should not have categories or be linked to as a way to avoid the regulations of the wiki. The exception to this is when a template is being used with automatic categories.
Rationale: to keep citizen stuff on citizen page, editor stuff in user space.

Lets rephrase this as "if possible." The issue is that when you categorize a page in your sandbox, it puts the article in the category. So lets say someone is browsing through articles in a category, your unfinished sandbox page will be there too. I would think that you would want your unfinished page to stay a bit private. So if you are writing an article in the sandbox, it is best to put the categories on once it has been moved to the main space. --QJ Lincoln Talk To Me 22:27, 2 July 2010 (UTC)
Then a more practical compromise would just to use the [[:Category:Sample]] technique and remove the colon when the article is deployed. Icon-USA.png - Jameson L. Tai talk/United States Rangers 23:48, 2 July 2010 (UTC)
Yes, but... When you will be testing a citizen template or organization template, or any other template that will have automatic categorization it will cause problems. Neither one sysop will make you problems if you are testing on your user sandbox this kind of templates and it causes and automatic category, for example Citizens category. And I know that you will now say, why then you don't put this notice into the policy? Because this kind of a testing should be done with input of other editors... The only thing that we could ADD to this policy is sentence like this: If you are going to test template with will have option to create automatic categories, use eRepublik:Bar to announce this. --AndyCro Icon-Croatia.png Click here to talk with me baby! ;) 10:41, 3 July 2010 (UTC)

Votes

8-1 for the policy.
User pages are for the the wiki editor to talk about his or her real life or wiki contributions. The user talk pages are used to leave messages/have conversations with wiki editors. The user namespace can and should be used for the development of articles or templates. Pages in the user name space should not have categories or be linked to as a way to avoid the regulations of the wiki. The exception to this is when a template is being used with automatic categories. 0 I believe that there should be some exceptions to this. For instance, the Uber Editor category, and the Wiki Project categories (if they are still being used). Other than the need to include these, I am in favour of this change.

Templates

Templates should be created and used as needed. Templates should be created to regularize content, provide notices to users, or to aid in the navigation of game explanation/instruction pages. Templates not used, not used on multiple pages, or serve the same purpose as the category, will be removed by the sysops. User signatures should not be templates."

Rationale: Management of the template category.

This is only directed for the creation of templates, not use. Usage is on Help:Common templates. Templates not used are deleted. A template should not be created for one page only. Templates that serve the same purpose as a category is directed at the tons of nav box templates we got rid of months ago that would have "Regions of Country" and "Parties of Country." These were too much of a pain to keep updated during war or party name changes. --QJ Lincoln Talk To Me 22:32, 2 July 2010 (UTC)
  • Then what about userspace templates used on main article space pages? Your policy has way too many loopholes for this to be actually useful. Icon-USA.png - Jameson L. Tai talk/United States Rangers 00:01, 3 July 2010 (UTC)

Autoplay

Autoplay of music or videos is not allowed in the wiki. Users may use Template:Video to embed videos on wiki pages.
Rationale.It is annoying to open a page and be blasted by music.

I can read any page in the wiki I want, I don't want to be assaulted by shitty music.... this isn't myspace. If I want to play the video or music, I will click to play it. Don't force it on people.... --QJ Lincoln Talk To Me 22:34, 2 July 2010 (UTC)
  • Then you should also regulate how these videos are displayed. Sizing of the video boxes so that users may click play/pause, etc. That should be regulated as well. I agree that certain articles where they put autoplay on but make the box size 1px X 1px is wrong, but for those who put the pause button in clear sight, they should not be forced to turn it off. Icon-USA.png - Jameson L. Tai talk/United States Rangers 00:03, 3 July 2010 (UTC)

Votes

7-1 for the policy, 2 abstain.

Personal tools
Namespaces
Variants
Actions
Wiki
Miscellaneous
Editors
Toolbox